Here are extracts from reviews of ESL Extras:
QATESOL, 2017, review by Mary Tibben: Maybe Next Year
This is the first in a series of six progressive readers for adult English language learners. It comprises a small format reader and an audio CD, as well as an A4 teacher’s guide and workbook. The workbook contains the full text of the reader and a range of activities. All materials are fully photocopiable.
I have been using the material with my class of beginners, who are really enjoying working through it. They appreciate the simple, everyday language, which does not in any way talk down to them. They also relate well to the family whose lives are portrayed through the stories, which provide many opportunities for extended discussion. ‘Very nice book, teacher,’ they tell me regularly.
From the teacher’s perspective there are many features of the resource that I really value. I like the way that the story is broken into eight 3-page sections, each telling part of the story from the perspective of a different member of the family. This makes it very practical for a beginner class. We can read one section repeatedly over the course of a week or two, completing the activities as we go, and then move on to a different section, without the students being overwhelmed. I also appreciate the wide variety of activities provided in the workbook. These include not only simple questions about the story, but word-searches, spot-the-difference, oral activities, writing activities and more. I love the fact that everything is photocopiable – a real bonus!
The only concern I have with the resource is with the CD. While it is read with authentic intonation, and good Aussie accents, the pace is really too fast for beginners. Even after reading the text several times in class, the students find it difficult to follow the CD. A slower pace would make it more beginner-friendly. However, this is a minor gripe. Overall, I can thoroughly recommend these resources to anyone working with adults learning English. They are excellent value for money.
QATESOL, 2017, review by Su Murgatroyd: Six Stories from Hope Street
It’s not always easy to find good, age appropriate, Australian readers for lower level adult ESL learners. That’s why I was excited when I saw the Six Stories from Hope Street resources written by Clare Harris and published by The Book Next Door.
There’s a library reader with audio CD and a photocopiable teacher’s guide and workbook which has the full text of the reader, well-designed worksheets and fun activities (saving on preparation time), useful teacher/ tutor notes and an audio CD
The resources are aimed at beginner level adults and young adults. The stories are about familiar topics and are written in the simple past tense using everyday language.
I love that this book and four other books in the ESL Extras series (including a free book downloadable at http://www.thebooknextdoor.com/esl-book/free-book-my-job-is-the-best/) are all set in Hope Street. I can choose stories that align with the main focus of my lesson and my students are still in familiar reading territory.
I teach a small beginner class once a week and we now have a regular story time where we read, listen, learn new vocabulary and write our own stories using these resources.
TESOLANZ (New Zealand), August 2016, by Gwenna Finikin, ESOL teacher, Hokowhitu Primary School
“…as I did not have access to adult learners, I used my senior primary students who enjoyed helping me write this review.
My students with lower reading ability particularly enjoyed being able to listen to the stories and found them interesting and funny. They also enjoyed the activities they were given. The books and activities are well set out with black and white pictures. The workbooks are designed to be photocopied and are very clear. There is no 10% copyright rule and Harris encourages teachers to copy as much as needed for their learners. The CDs are there to be copied as well so learners can take them home with their booklets for on-going practice. The author gives ideas of different ways to use each book and ways of using them for different levels.
Welcome to Hope Street was designed to provide take-home material for preliminary learners. It has repeated text and structure providing plenty of picture scaffolding and introducing characters from later in the series. If a teacher were to work through it in one of the suggested ways, the book could span eight weeks of lessons and the learners would then have eight stories to take home as folded booklets, as well as the CD to listen to in their own time. Each story has four pages of associated work, including questions for teachers to ask, a cut-up picture/story match, and letter and word activities. There is also a vocabulary game at the end. My students enjoyed this book a lot, even though their reading level was beyond it.
The Garage Sale is a beginner level book written in simple past tense. It is fun to read. The book is split into six chapters. The workbook comes with four pages of activities per chapter. Harris has given many suggestions on how to use the workbook….The board game at the end of this book works on ‘this/that/these/those’. My students enjoyed the humour of the book and the twist in Chapter 6.
Can You Keep a Secret? is an elementary level book with more difficult sentence structure and vocabulary than the previous books. … Following the main idea would mean the lesson series would last eight weeks with a lot of opportunity to work on tenses, structure, and comprehension. This book contained more subtle humour that my students missed but adults would relate to. My students enjoyed the story, understood the worries of the protagonist and liked the twist at the end.
Harris has provided a teacher and learner friendly series of books for adults, using real-life situations and humour. She has spoken to other teachers about the types of resources they want and has produced a series that can be used in multiple ways and can be easily changed to work with different levels. They are designed to be supplements within formal or informal programmes. The books’ strengths lie in the stories as well as the numerous activities and the ability to multi-purpose the resources; teachers could work through the resources, or pick-and-choose, or come up with their own activities.
The one weakness of the series is that, as technologies develop, it is getting harder to find computers with disk drives to play and make copies of the CDs. It may be that Harris and her publishers need to look at providing downloadable MP3s so that those without drives can access and distribute the audio content. My students and I enjoyed looking through the resources and we will be using them in the future.”
WATESOL (Western Australia): April 2015, by Samantha Vanderford, Independent ESL Consultant
Clare Harris (www.thebooknextdoor.com) has crafted two interesting and exciting short stories with a twist at the end for adult learners of English as a second language. The stories, both set in Australia, carry along at a fast pace with clear language and basic, perhaps universal, concepts.
The Coat is a story that moves along at break-neck speed with twists and interesting characters, which would appeal to both young and older adults. The Coat tells the story of a young woman who has moved to Melbourne to start her own business leaving her boyfriend in Brisbane. She needs a warm coat because of the cold weather and that coat leads her through questions of love and ethics. The language is at a pre-intermediate level and remains so throughout the book. The grammar is explicit in the text.
Can You Keep a Secret? is a story that would appeal to migrant adults, particularly those with families and jobs. The story centers on George a migrant who is up for a promotion at work but he is asked to keep it secret from his colleagues and family. This moral issue along with George’s concern that his English is not adequate for the job and a birthday party make for a highly entertaining sequence of events with a twist at the end. The language starts at an elementary level and progressively gets more difficult ending up at a pre intermediate level.
The language and the concepts in these two stories encourage the reader to read for meaning and not get bogged down in the language. It is understandable that the author has termed these readers “easy-read” stories and allocated them to the elementary/ pre-intermediate level (CSWE 1,2,3 depending on the level of support provided by the teacher)…
Certainly, one could get picky and say that there are some minor problems with the worksheets (e.g., multiple choice word quiz choices are more complex than the question in some instances). However, the positives of the worksheets outweigh the negatives. For example, the extra language rules for the past tense, similes, collocations, half and half sentences, tables and categorization exercises teach the students excellent learning strategies for analyzing language. Further, the answers are provided.
In summary, if you want to find books for your students that they will read with interest through to the end and go on to read others after, these books are a great choice. With this excellent set of materials, Clare Harris, the author, has certainly achieved her five goals for students, which are 1) reading for enjoyment, 2) fluency and pronunciation development, 3) vocabulary and idiom learning, 4) confidence with narratives and recounts, and 5) achievable comprehension review.
A link to a Blogger’s Review from Amanda Kendle (and disclaimer, I know her!)